WhiteAfrican

Where Africa and Technology Collide!

Africa’s small merchants and payments

I’ve been pondering small business, payments and incentives quite a bit recently. Partly because of the web startups I’ve been seeing crop up locally, partly due to the inefficiencies in the system, and also because I’m a bit of a merchant at heart.

Specifically, I think that small business in Africa will bring a major wave of activity in the online space. That some smart startups will take advantage of mobiles and the internet, and will be beneficiaries of this growth. We’re all quite impressed with the peer-to-peer mobile money growth on the continent, but those numbers pales in comparison to what can be done with high penetration of active merchant payment options.

The African Payments Picture

A recent post about Square (the merchant payment system for iOS devices) and their use by small businesses started me thinking beyond the mobile peer-to-peer payments we’re so focused on here in Kenya and more in the direction of the merchant side. Right now Square moves $4 million per day, a healthy business, but not a massive amount compared to the big guys in the field. Most merchants in the US and Europe default to having some type of credit card or bank card payment setup for customers, it’s almost a given.

Meanwhile, in Africa it’s a different story. Mobile payments have taken the stage due to the lack of credit/debit card penetration. In short, African’s lack payment options, so innovative ways to use what they do have (phones) has pushed payment innovation forward.

While the mobile operators have been busy diversifying their revenue streams and figuring out new ways to hook in their subscribers with mobile money, the banks haven’t been nearly as active. Many of them would rather just create a mobile way to check your balance, rather than provide a tool with truly meaningful interaction, something you could pass money through to merchants or your contacts. Instead of offering something of equal, or better, value they’ve instead chosen to try and block the operators movements.

As I’ve suggested many times, we need an agnostic system, where the user isn’t penalized for their choice of mobile operator or bank.

New Ideas

While the big players continue to fight it out, the small players are innovating where they can. We’re seeing mobile payment aggregators, such as PesaPal, begin to see success as their web options catch on with merchants, schools and events. Meanwhile, groups like KopoKopo are going further down the stack, providing a subscription-based mobile payments processing package for SMEs.

New startups like Niko Hapa are creating locally-relevant incentive systems for merchants that works with everyday customers. Others, like M-Order, are creating simplified mobile and web-based ordering systems for customers to order services and products. MIH-backed Dealfish and Ringier-backed Rupu/Pigia continue to duke it out against each other across sub-saharan Africa, getting small merchants to list their goods on their marketplaces.

What I’m pointing out is that we have a wave of new products and services specifically aimed at merchants. Most of them are small and don’t have critical mass, but that is changing rapidly. These are just the first movers.

Shifting Sands

Bonk is a t-shirt company in Nairobi that offers the coolest designs around for their target market of urban Nairobians, and they have a shop set up in a nice shopping center in town (Junction). Let’s call them the high-end of the small merchants who need a good way to get payments. Their current setup allowing Visa transactions account for around half of their customers, and they have to pay a rather large 5% transaction fee. They don’t have an online store (yet… Shame on them.), so walk-ins are their only sales channel and they do very well with them.

Other examples of small businesses that run the range of medium- to lower-level transactions would be auto parts stores, retail clothes shops and restaurants. They all have a need to attract customers and they are all served better by having an easier way to setup a merchant account and have easier ways for their clientele to pay.

There are hundreds of thousands of these small businesses across Africa. Few of them have any solution other than cash. Companies that accept credit cards, like Bonk, are the anomaly.

A Hybrid Solution

What would a Square-type solution look like for them? What if a company were to create a simple (for customers) payment system that solved the problem that Square is solving? That is, a way to get your hands on a solution easily, without oversized transaction fees, and which also worked within the local context of mobile payments plus credit cards.

I can imagine someone coming up with an device that works on most phones. Probably Android phones here instead of iOS devices. That way, as a merchant I can buy an $80 IDEOS Android phone, get one of these swiping devices, that also has a chip in it for near-field communication payments and which seamlessly works with Mpesa and other mobile payment options. It’s simplified, and it works across not just a country, but across the continent.

What would this device look like? How could it connect to the phone? What type of technology would be embedded in it to make it work right? Which merchant systems could be signed on in order to allow people to signup and get started?

12 Comments

  1. We are trying to crack this space as well, but you must know that challenges exist in the hardware hack side. Thomas of Ringier challenged me yesterday over an opportunity discussion…”go to China for 3 months”. And that I just might do as there is an ingredient missing in our kitchen.

  2. Seems a swedish company has come up with something similar you are describing. Check it out: http://izettle.com/

  3. Great post, Erik. We’re watching this space, too. M-Pesa has over 14M subscribers and only ~ 500 Buy Goods and Pay Bill partners. Lots of room to grow.

  4. Ben, I didn’t know it was only 500 enterprise/business partners on Mpesa. That’s a huge market they’re missing.

  5. Concise and clear post: This is not only an African problem but an emerging market one. We are already working in this area and believe we’ve cracked it albeit we are a pre-revenue startup looking for funding in order to execute on our model and prototype. Would be interested to hear your thoughts.

  6. Hi Hash, great post, big fun of your blog. Not sure if you are aware of InMobi’s SmartPay, which solves what you describe above. Admittedly in Africa, it is currently live in just South Africa . http://www.inmobi.com/inmobiblog/2011/05/10/announcing-inmobi-smartpay%E2%84%A2-simple-intelligent-global-mobile-payments/

  7. just to add to above – SmartPay is not a competitor to the existing Mobile Payments solutions but complements them; cheers

  8. this is great food for thought, there is so much oppurtunity here especially considering the little market percentage that is actually captured by Mpesa,incorporating a simple safe payment system would be wonderful for businesses.

  9. For sure.
    After “ATM” like mobile money, real mobile commerce looks like a natural evolution.
    Not sure there is need for physical device though (a la Square or iZettle), managing even simple physical airtime vouchers has proven to be challenging and many carriers have moved into virtual airtime distribution (the actual ancestor of mobile money).
    Also, try to convince a local small micro-merchant to pay 2% of their revenues for accepting a new payment mechanism… while cash is “tangible, free and sadly tax free”.

    There is need for adding a lot more value and getting hands dirty …beyond simple payments !
    @tkanet

  10. Nice post – a welcome summary for those of us watching African developments in mobile payments from Europe. A question to be addressed I would have to add to yours is about fraud potential / prevention. How do you develop the system to prevent uncovered fraud losses like this: http://www.gmeltdown.com/2010/02/m-pesa-fraud-agents-beware.html

  11. I just bought a waterpump Chinese model from the local Davis & shirtif at 182$ instead of the Japanese model at 526$ .it took a couple of weeks of asking different people to find out the only difference between the two models is that one can run for ten hours without overheating .
    While I do appreciate the innovative work by African techpreneurs, as a consumer I feel left out.
    As an African I am a walk-in customer. You wouldn’t catch me dead buying an item
    online. So how do you get my money?
    The challenge is not to create the best payment solution but how to link up to my needs.
    Team up with irrigation equipment suppliers and consultants and have content I can acess from the local supplier they then can teach me how to use my phone to use acess content.
    Trust is very important. I trust Davis & shartif, I trust M-pesa, I trust Nakumatt and citizen Radio & T.V .
    payment solution providers should focus on the people we trust

  12. This is an interesting technology that could well be the payment gateway of choice in the future, my only concern is the security and the opportunity for fraud.

Comments are closed.

© 2019 WhiteAfrican

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑